Kansas City Chiefs Trade Tyreek Hill to Miami…

NFL Offseason – All great things must come to an end, including the era of the Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl LIV-winning trio of Patrick Mahomes, Tyreek Hill and Travis Kelce.

The salary cap-strapped Chiefs traded Hill to the Miami Dolphins on Wednesday in exchange for first, second and fourth-round picks in the 2022 draft, plus fourth and sixth rounders in 2023, per ESPN’s Adam Schefter. The trade came suddenly after contract extension talks between the Chiefs and Hill fell apart. 

Hill finished seventh in the NFL in DYAR in 2021, the fourth top-10 finish of his six-year career. He caught a career-high 111 passes for 1,239 yards and 9 touchdowns, earning Pro Bowl honors for a sixth consecutive season. 

But seriously, you darn know who Hill is, and it’s silly to try to summarize his impact in a short paragraph of stats and accomplishments. He’s the NFL’s most electrifying big-play threat and one of its most thrilling players to watch. He has been an almost-indispensable key to the success of Mahomes and the Chiefs offense with his ability to both lift the lid on the secondary and turn any screen pass or end-around into a game-changing play. Mahomes remains an outstanding quarterback without Hill, but he’s likely to look a little less extraordinary now that Hill will no longer force opposing safeties to play 15 yards off the ball on nearly every snap.

The Hill trade may have done more to shift the balance of power in the NFL than any of this offseason’s blockbuster trades, even the Deshaun Watson deal. 

Tyreek Hill Trade Impact on the Miami Dolphins

The Dolphins appear to be throwing their hats into the ring as short-term AFC contenders. That’s nearly a 180-degree philosophical shift from about 72 hours ago, when the franchise was concentrating on modest free-agent acquisitions and seemed content to build slowly under new head coach Mike McDaniel.

Hill provides score-from-anywhere capability for an offense that already features a credible big-play threat with broadly similar skills (Jaylen Waddle), some free-agent newcomers (Cedric Wilson, special teams ace Trent Sherfield), a seam-stretching tight end (Mike Gesiicki) and an oft-injured veteran possession receiver (DeVante Parker), plus some new faces at running back. (Free agent receiver Will Fuller is not expected to return). On paper, the new Dolphins receiving corps looks better than even the Hill-Kelce-Sammy Watkins Super Bowl LIV arsenal. 

The Dolphins also added former New Orleans Saints All-Pro left tackle Terron Armstead on Tuesday and former Dallas Cowboys guard Connor Williams last week in an effort to improve an offensive line which finished 30th in adjusted line yards and dead last in pass block win rate last year and hamstrung the entire Dolphins offense.

Now, about the quarterback.

Tua Tagovailoa never earned the trust of the previous coaching regime. He was cocooned within an RPO-intensive offense and appeared to be in danger of a quick hook after every mistake. Former San Francisco 49ers offensive coordinator McDaniel was hired to jumpstart Tua’s development with the help of a YAC-heavy system. 

Hill can both unlock the Dolphins’ deep passing attack and contribute in a 49ers-style catch-and-run game. His presence will also open up opportunities for other receivers. Tagovailoa is almost certain to succeed with the rebuilt Dolphins playmaking corps, because Chase Daniel’s accountant could succeed with the rebuilt Dolphins playmaking corps. If he somehow cannot, Teddy Bridgewater was signed as a fail-safe Jimmy Garoppolo surrogate.

Tyreek Hill Trade Impact on the Kansas City Chiefs

The Chiefs now have two first-round and two second-round picks in the 2022 draft, and they need them. Cornerbacks Charvarius Ward and Mike Hughes headline the free-agent departures from a defense which finished 24th in DVOA but was historically bad for part of the year. Hill’s departure gives the Chiefs the cap flexibility to re-sign All-Pro safety Tyrann Mathieu, who appears to want to stay with the organization.

So the Chiefs traded one superstar for the necessary resources to rebuild an entire defense. In that respect, the Hill trade is downright practical. But it also robs the Chiefs of their mythic, magical quality. From 2019-21, Andy Reid’s Mahomes-Hill-Kelce Chiefs were not just perennial Super Bowl contenders but potential harbingers of a new era of anything-goes sandlot-style football. Now the Chiefs are just another NFL team, quantitatively still among the contenders but qualitatively no different from everyone else.

Tyreek Hill Trade Impact on the AFC

The Hill trade has an impact that extends beyond the Dolphins and Chiefs:

• The Buffalo Bills are now even more prohibitive favorites to win both the AFC and the Super Bowl.
• The New England Patriots, who have been treading water this offseason, now appear to be the third-best team in the AFC East. DraftKings has the Patriots and Dolphins at +400 each to win the division (the Bills are at a stunning -190).
• The Denver Broncos and Los Angeles Chargers have all but caught up to the Chiefs in the AFC West. The house still lists the Chiefs at +165 to win the division, but the Russell Wilson-buffed Broncos are at +220 and the Chargers at +275. 

The 2022 AFC playoff race looks as wide-open an unpredictable as any we have seen since before Tom Brady led the Patriots to supremacy. Yes, we know the Bills will be at or near the top. But there are nearly a dozen teams who could be up there beside them. And even the Dolphins are now on that list.